Darwinian Revolution — Unit 1
PRE-DARWINIAN THOUGHT

  • Evolution:
    • as a process
    • as a theory
    • in relation to other sciences and cultural trends
  • Traditions of Greek and Roman thought:
    • Why Greek & Roman? What about China, India, etc.?

  • The Greek nature-philosophers:
    • Thales (of Miletus, c.620-546 BCE):
      "Lover of wisdom" (ϕιλοδοϕος); calculated solstices, equinioxes; predicted eclipse of 585 BCE;
      arche=water; earth floats on water; legends: fell into well; olive presses.
    • Anaximander (of Miletus, c.610-546 BCE):
      Apeiron (απειρον) and two forces (love, hate); separation of opposites;
      cycles of creation and destruction; life originated from seabed; humans originated from fish
    • Parmenides (of Elea in Sicily, fl. 500 BCE):
      Nothing comes from nothing; no void exists;
      "that which exists" is unchanging because it cannot be destroyed or become nothingness.
    • Heracleitos=Heraclitus (of Ephesus in Ionia, c.535-475 BCE):
      "All is flux"; "You cannot step into the same river twice"; fire [?energy] in everything;
      "drunkenness damages the soul; a virtuous life keeps the soul dry and intelligent"
    • Empedocles (of Acragas=Agrigentum in Sicily, c.490-430 BCE):
      Four elements (earth, water, air, fire) and 2 forces;     cyclical history: age of strife=chaos, struggle with love (produces life), age of harmony and pure love, struggle with hate, dissolution into strife and chaos, etc.
    • Leucippus (of Miletus, fl. 5th cent BCE): originated atomic theory
    • Democritus (of Abdera in Thrace, 460-370 BCE): details of atomic theory; sheep on hillside analogy.
    • (eclipse of this tradition)
    • Epicurus (born Athens but expelled to Samos, 341-270 BCE):
      Revived naturalist tradition; taught followers to seek pleasure (freedom from pain and fear) by practicing moderatioon in all things.
    • Lucretius (Roman, 99-55 BCE): Summarized all the foregoing ideas.     Lucretius quote

  • The classical tradition (mostly Athenian at first):
    • Protagoras (c.490-420 BCE) and the sophists:
      Emphasis on human affairs (law courts), argumentation.   "Man is the measure of all things...."
    • Socrates (470-399 BCE):
      Rejected ethical relativism; emphasis on logical and ethical standards
    • Plato (c.428-347 BCE):
      • the eidos (ειδος) and the theory of forms ("theory of ideas")
    • Aristotle (384-322 BCE):
      • Extension of the theory of forms; essentialism
      • Genus and species
      • Causation and teleology     Four types of cause
      • Hierarchy of "souls" (psyche, ψϒχή)
    • Theophrastus (c.371-287 BCE)
    • (eclipse of this tradition)
    • (Medieval times — eclipse of learning in general)
    • Revival under Christianity: Augustine, Aquinas
    • Great Chain of Being (Scala naturae)     Pope
    • Descriptive botany in northern Europe (see below)
    • Linnaeus— codification of the classical tradition in biology
  • Science in the Renaissance:
    • Anatomy and art in southern Europe: Michelangelo, Vesalius     Examples
    • Descriptive botany, pharmacology, and art in northern Europe     Examples
    • Printing and Protestantism
    • Galileo, Newton, and astronomy
    • Formation of scientific communities, esp. the Royal Society

  • Environmentalism (esp. in France):
    • Renaissance explorers and geographers
    • Enlightenment ("Age of Reason") and the French Revolution (1789)
    • Alexander von Humboldt
  • Adaptation:   Describing it;   Explaining it
  • Environmental determinism — but it needs a mechanism
    • Buffon and migration
    • Maupertius
    • Lamarck:       "La Marche de la Nature";     Theory of use and disuse
    • Geoffroy (Isidore Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire)
    • Erasmus Darwin
    • Environmentalism in literature (Zola, Dickens, etc.)
  • Divine benevolence and "Natural theology" (mostly in England):
    • Aquinas
    • John Ray
    • Hume and Kant
    • William Paley
    • Earl of Bridgewater
  • Geology before Darwin:
    • Nature of fossils: Xenophanes, Herodotus, DaVinci, Steno
    • Age of the Earth ; de Maillet and "Telliamed"
    • Catastrophism (from ancient Greece to Werner and Cuvier)
              Ray, Werner, Smith, Cuvier, Sedgwick
    • Uniformitarianism
  • Cuvier and comparative anatomy
  • German romanticism and Naturphilosophie:
    • Oken; literary influences
    • Bauplan theory & homology: Goethe ("Alles ist Blatt"), Owen and homology
    • Embryology: Meckel, Von Baer, Haeckel
    • Cell theory: Schleiden, Schwann, Virchow

Syllabus
Prev rev. Dec. 2014 Next